
CURAT3D: Jordan Lyall - Unveiling the Wonders of Generative Art, Memes in the Crypto and DeFi Universe
Summary
Send us a text Strap in for a stellar conversation with the one and only Jordan Lyall—an OG in the crypto and DeFi universe. We're diving deep into generative art and its revolutionary impact on the NFT terrain, alongside a rich discussion about meme communities and Jordan's innovative project, Prohibition Art. Journey with Jordan as he recounts his adventurous foray into the DeFi world and the golden opportunities it has unfolded. Relive the legendary 'DeFi Summer' of 2020 and the meme plat...Speaker 1: GM.
This is Boone and you're
listening to the Schiller
Curated Podcast.
In this week's episode, we sat
down with Jordan Lyle.
Jordan is a true OG in the
crypto and DeFi space.
He is the founder of
Prohibition Art, venturepunk
Skylab and previously worked at
Consensus.
We chat everything from his
love of generative art and took
an in-depth look at the meme
community, the ideas behind
Prohibition Art and how
generative art and NFTs will
eventually eat the world.
As always, this podcast is for
entertainment purposes only and
should not be relied upon for
financial advice.
Boone and guests may own NFTs
discussed.
Now it's time to grab some
coffee and dive into this
conversation with Jordan.
And it's awesome, man.
I love that you got the mic
with you, man.
It's a rare treat as a
podcaster to interview.
Most people don't have the mic
set up, so it's really great to
have it there.
Man, how are you, jordan, doing
great Boone, how you doing Good
man, good, it's finally here in
Austin.
It's actually whether where I
want to go outside and do things
Really, you know.
Speaker 2: So it's not 100
degrees, it's only 90 degrees,
or what's the situation?
Speaker 1: Yeah, well, it's been
for a while.
That was the situation and it
was like wow.
What people didn't understand
is that 86 degrees or 90 degrees
was like a 13-degree cold front
.
You know what I mean.
Like that was.
It took me a little while to
realize that, but it's actually
been high 50s, low 60s in the
morning and it'll get up to high
70s, mid 80s, kind of that
range.
So it's been nice.
Man, that is pretty nice.
Speaker 2: Enjoy it while you
can right, or do you think it'll
be nice for the rest of the
fall?
Speaker 1: So what's interesting
about Texas is that October is
like.
So October and March are kind
of like these wild card months
where you could get an extra
month of summer, but not maybe
as intense, you know, but it's
still.
You're like fuck, this just
doesn't feel like fall, or you
could get super cold, or you
could get cold and rainy, or you
could get really nice weather
like this.
And March is kind of the same
way, where it's Texas doesn't
really know if it's what it
wants to do and it doesn't
really.
I guess it just doesn't compute
or doesn't fully comprehend
what spring and fall means.
So yeah, man, so far so good.
We just take it day by day.
That's really the vibe here.
There you go.
Speaker 2: There you go.
Yeah Well, I hate to brag, of
course, but it's 70 degrees
right now where I'm at at the
beach in Southern California,
and that's probably on the
colder side lately, slightly
cloudy, I think.
When we hit 80 or 85, then it's
like everyone's just tripping
and sweating, Everyone's
complaining and everyone's
horrible.
That's like a nice day for you,
but that would be rough for us.
Speaker 1: Well, I really
appreciate you guys pushing
through that when you guys were
in Austin, because I don't think
we quite hit that massive heat
wave, but it was probably a heat
wave to you when we were there
downtown.
Speaker 2: Yeah, that was pretty
warm man.
Speaker 1: And I remember the
building.
If I remember right, the
building didn't have AC or
wasn't ventilated that well.
If I remember that right.
I haven't flashbacked.
Speaker 2: No, like yeah,
there's no air flow or anything.
So I think that's why we spend
most of the time outside, right.
Speaker 1: Yeah yeah, it's kind
of brutal when you know when
you're trying to hang out
outside in Texas, that's how you
know it's rough.
Speaker 2: And I run hot as it
is, I am always just sweating
and like, so I'm always trying
to keep the temperature down and
I'm not used to any humidity,
Like we're at the beach.
So there's like we just don't
get that Used to the dry heat as
well.
So, yeah, I'm just not.
You know, you walk out and
you're just already drenched and
you need to take another shower
.
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean you and
me are very similar.
We run hot.
I can't tell you why I've lived
in Texas my entire life, but
two years, you know it doesn't.
It suits me well for the
environment that I'm in, I guess
, or for the job description
that, or the, I guess, the
community that I like to spend
most of my time in.
You know, so I guess you could.
Who knows if I would have
actually touched grass more than
I stayed inside if I lived in
Colorado.
I may not be here.
You know the thing in.
Speaker 2: Colorado, like you're
contractually obligated to go
touch grass a couple times a
week.
Right, it seems like everyone
in Colorado goes and they're
outdoorsy and they're very
active.
Speaker 1: Well it's.
I mean there's such a strong
incentive to do so.
I mean there's only there's
only like two places in the
entire state that are just not
drop dead gorgeous, you know,
and it's just everywhere you go
out there's a hiking trail and
it's very similar to California
weather, unless you're like kind
of like in Metropolis, like in
Denver or in like Fort Collins
that's.
You know, they can get a little
toasty there, but anywhere
outside of like the main city
you're going to get really great
like hiking weather and you can
go outside and you cannot dive
heat, exhaustion, and you know
it's just wonderful things that
you don't get here.
Speaker 2: I may have told you,
but we have it spoiled here by
the beach where beach people.
My son actually is a freshman
in high school and for his PE he
goes and surfs twice a week.
So he has high school credit to
go surf every other more.
Speaker 1: That's incredible, I
had no idea that existed.
Speaker 2: Yeah, wow, wow.
Speaker 1: A very.
You know, I I growing up with
the beach like we didn't, I, you
can't, you can't really call
Galveston a beach Like it's.
It's not really, you just can't
, it's like it's the closest
thing to a beach.
Well, I take it back.
Corpus.
We have Corpus Christi.
You know that's, that's, that's
nice beach weather or like
clear water.
But the fact that he gets to do
that and that's he's a freshman
in high school and he gets to
do that, yeah, wow, wow.
Times have changed.
Has that always been like that?
I'm curious.
Speaker 2: I think for the, for
the local high school.
Yeah, that's, that's kind of
always been an option.
You know you pass a swim test
and you have to.
You know there's certain rules,
but yeah, he's every Tuesday
and Thursday, you know, in in
the ocean for an hour and then
he goes to, you know, normal
class, like at 1030.
Speaker 1: What a life man.
That's incredible.
Um, yeah, I was.
I was a swimmer in high school,
for, well, I swam before high
school, so I swam competitively
for 10 years and then, you know,
that includes high school, but
we were, we were in the water at
545 and then, uh, and then we
were in class by first period.
Like, we didn't like, we didn't
have the like.
It would have been great if, if
swim practice started at, like,
first period and that took up
two to three periods of school.
Uh, that would have been
phenomenal, but we didn't get
that luxury.
Um, but, yeah, that's, that's
awesome, man.
Well, I mean, I want to say
thanks for like making some time
, uh, and appreciate you being
flexible for coming on here.
Dude, it's been, you know, for
those that don't know, we've
gotten to like know each other a
little bit over the past couple
of months.
Uh, you know, and working with
you guys with prohibition and
just the more like.
I just got to say like, uh, the
.
You know I I kind of sat by and
watched generative art from the
sidelines in 2021.
I didn't fully.
It wasn't the first art form
that I truly comprehended or
grasped, you know.
So I kind of just, you know I'm
one of those people that I try
to not get involved for the
wrong reasons, like, if it's
like, okay, just because there's
value attached to it.
But if I don't, it doesn't make
me feel anything.
I don't want to.
You know, I don't want to buy
it.
So I kind of sat there quietly
and watched on the sidelines, um
.
And so you guys came around and
, um, it allowed me to be like
to actually approach generative
art in like such a more like
thoughtful way, you know like
where it's like I could take my
time, there was no FOMO attached
to it and I just want to thank
you for like, like having the
spark to do that, cause it's
been, it's been a treat to like
not rush into the genre and
medium that is generative art.
So I massive props and I just
want to appreciate.
I just wanted to thank you
publicly for that.
Speaker 2: Uh, it's so cool to
hear man cause, that's kind of
why we're here, right, that's
kind of what we're doing is like
I had so much fun several years
ago minting on art blocks and,
um, I just want to kind of
transfer that enthusiasm and
give that experience to others,
newcomers to the space, people
like you who have kind of maybe
been on the sidelines, um, you
know, to others who are brand
new or non non native just yet.
Uh, so that really why
prohibition is to hear it is
here, is is to spread, you know,
on chain generative art to as
many people as possible.
Speaker 1: Yeah, man, it's uh,
and I think you guys are doing
it like, like I said, you guys
have something special there and
there's a lot.
We can unpack that and some of
the decisions behind that um as
well.
But one thing I wanted to take
a little step back is, you know,
you mentioned you had such like
a good time minting, like in
summer 2021.
And when that whole, when the
whole art blocks thing happened,
um, I guess I'm curious, you
know, cause it, there's a lot of
people that this really like it
just really sucked a lot of
people in.
You know, it just drew a lot of
people in.
It was this, uh, it was this
really cool event.
It felt like an evolution, um,
to generate art.
It felt like the right way to
transact it.
So I'm just like, what were
kind of the steps to you even
learning about this art form?
Were you into it?
Into it like before you know
the blockchain existed?
Were you did?
Yeah, just very curious, like
your intro to this.
Speaker 2: Uh, I had actually
launched an NFT platform before
art blocks did.
Um, so, yeah, we can dig into
my whole backstory.
But, uh, summer of 2020, um,
start there for a second summer
of 2020, uh, I and a few few
friends we launched a um, we
launched an NFT platform called
meme.
It was a meme token, and that's
how it's called built by
memecom, and you would stake the
meme token and you would earn
points and then those points
would be redeemable for NFTs.
Um, so I was aware of NFTs.
I was building on NFTs, working
with artists.
Um, I was, I was in deep, uh,
and even then I mean similar to
what you were saying earlier I
was aware of of art blocks, I
was aware of generative art, but
it took me a few times of other
people sharing it, of, uh,
different uh podcasts, different
interviews, reading up on it.
It took several times, uh,
before I got it and got how
interesting it is.
And, to be honest, you know,
when I first minted on art
blocks, it was only because, uh,
things that minted on art
blocks the next day would five X
right.
So it was.
I'm not I don't consider myself
a trader, but it was like, for
a short period of time it was,
it was dumb not to mint because
they were just, uh, they were
just, you know, selling like
crazy in the after, in the after
, uh, you know, in the secondary
.
But it really wasn't until you
know a few, a few experiences of
minting and, uh, you know,
buying off the secondary
generative art.
It's a little bit different
than you, you know, minting
generative art, because when
you're part of the minting
experience, like you don't know
what you're going to get, and
then it's actually you hitting,
uh, the mint button which helps
determine the outcome and the
output.
Um, so it took a few times for
me to get really into why this
is different, why this is unique
, why this isn't, this isn't
like a one of one or an addition
, uh, but once I did, I was, I
was hooked, um, so it's
definitely a process for me as
well.
Speaker 1: But even someone deep
enough into this space, who had
launched for several projects
at that point, uh it, it took me
a while to like sink in about
how unique and special this,
this generative art, you know,
especially long-form gen art
with that, uh, you know how
valuable it was yeah, dude,
that's a, that's a great intro
man, and I, yeah, I mean you, uh
, I'm, I'm happy to kind of have
a through line and piece
together your journey as we go
along here, Cause I mean, it's
deep and I think that's one of
the things that when we started
like working together and when
we started, uh, yeah, just
working together, it was like,
wow, like I, we, we throw the
term around OG a lot, you know,
but it's it's very few, I think,
that are still here, Um, and I
think you've definitely earned
your stripes in a lot of
different ways, and so it's
really, I guess it's really
comfortable to.
First and foremost, thanks for
uh just telling me like you
missed out on generational
wealth.
You know, um, for getting into
it with the wrong reason, for a
financial reason you know I try
to be super I guess I take
myself too seriously in that
respect is like, okay, who gives
the shit if it's a financial
opportunity?
You know, like it, it doesn't
matter why you got there, it's,
I think it matters why you stay,
you know, Um, so it's cool to
hear that.
You know, it's cool to hear
kind of your, your background
into doing that took you a
couple of times.
But was it kind of just like I'm
curious like how you learn
about new art forms, Like was it
kind of like a peer pressure
type of thing, or was it was
there, was there part of it that
just kept you coming back?
Or was it just kind of like a
general confusion of like
missing out on what other people
were, like being elated by, If
that makes sense yeah, it's a.
Speaker 2: That's a good one.
Um, this is a really weird time
in in uh, 2020, summer of 2020,
end of 2020.
Um, I was probably more focused
on building than I was uh,
collecting.
Um, you know, summer of 2020 is
what we call defy summer.
Right In retrospect, you see,
yeah, everyone was really
interested in in defy and uh,
their farming tokens and yield
had just launched wifi.
Um, it was.
It was crazy.
Um, so there is kind of this
opportunity.
I mean, I'd been, I've been in
the States for a long time.
I first got into Bitcoin in 2013
, I believe, and um, so I had,
you know, several ups and downs.
Uh, when I first bought Bitcoin
, it, it jumped up to 1600 or
wherever it was at, and fell
back down to a hundred Um plus.
Then you have the, the, you
know, the market correction of
2018.
Um so I was kind of like used
to market changes and market
swings and the, the cyclical
nature.
Um, so I I had developed over
the years just this thesis of
buy and hold.
Um, so I was never really one
to just buy something because
there's a chance it's going to
go up and try to sell it uh the
next day, or uh, or play some of
these hot potato type of games.
But it was really like from a
sense of building, where I
approached this and I mentioned
the meme platform that we had
launched.
It was really out of a desire
to create something fun and
silly in a sense.
I don't know how deep you want
to get into the meme project,
but it was like we have this
token.
Speaker 1: Go for it.
What's that?
It's deep as you want to go,
man.
Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2: Yeah, there's a lot
to discuss there, but, for the
sake of this story, I was
working in crypto at the time,
was working for consensus, the
big blockchain company,
consensus Thinking about, okay,
how do we get more users into
DeFi?
How do we get the normies into
DeFi?
My team and I actually launched
something called the DeFi Score
.
We were thinking a lot about
okay, how do we judge risk with
all these DeFi opportunities?
How does a newcomer see, okay,
if I stake my token here, if I
deposit, if I lend money on this
platform, what's the level of
risk versus lending on another
platform?
We were thinking a lot about
how do we keep this a safe place
for newcomers?
I was doing that by day, by
night.
I was just totally throwing
money into these crazy pools and
getting crazy returns for short
periods of time.
There have been times where I
degen and sometimes it works out
and sometimes it doesn't.
Most times it doesn't.
It was interesting.
During the day, I was thinking
about, okay, how do we protect
new users?
And then by night, I was doing
crazy things and taking risks on
chain.
I posted a tweet and it was a
really stupid tweet and you may
be saying, hey, all your tweets
are stupid.
What do you mean?
I posted a tweet.
It was like a fake product.
People were just like at this
time, people were creating crazy
lending pools and staking pools
and the YAM token was a thing.
And this was before things got
too crazy.
But it was in the height of
this crazy DeFi summer.
People, certain developers if a
certain wallet deploys a new
contract, within minutes, you'd
see tens of thousands, hundreds
of thousands of dollars just
jump into this contract, jump
into this pool, wow.
And then over a course of a
couple hours, you may see a
million dollars in this pool
because those early returns, as
people are just getting into it,
hearing more about it, you
could make a ton of money.
So it was this like developer.
It was this dichotomy between
developers that are just like
launching pools without testing
them thoroughly.
So a lot of people got burned.
How does a newcomer to DeFi,
how do they know how to navigate
this landscape?
There's so many landmines.
Speaker 1: That's a great saying
.
Speaker 2: I love that.
So, by day, again by day,
thinking about, okay, how do we
protect users?
By night participating and
trying not to lose all my money
but just experimenting with it,
and I guess that's another kind
of like.
Key point is just like being
curious, setting aside money
that you know you'll probably
lose, but I want to test it, I
want to see what is this thing
all about.
I'm willing to chalk up 50
bucks to convert it to whatever,
and because at the time I was a
product guy, I was always kind
of curious.
I want to build the next thing.
I want to help users on board.
So, anyways, back to the tweet.
I posted the silly tweet.
I actually made a fake product.
The product was called the
degenerator.
So instead of generator, it's
called the degenerator.
And it was this fake product
that made it really easy.
It was almost like WordPress
for DeFi protocols, where you
click a couple buttons, you type
in a couple phrases and you
choose an emoji, because at the
time a lot of projects back then
had vegetable emojis, had food
emoji.
It was pasta, there was yam,
which I had mentioned, there was
sushi, of course.
So that was kind of like part
of the joke and I posted this
thing that made it.
It wasn't a real product but a
lot of people thought it did.
But it was this mock up of a
fake product that allows you to
quickly spin up DeFi protocols.
I had posted that thinking that
I'd get a few friends to laugh
at it, that a few people would
retweet it.
Within the first few minutes it
took off.
It was really good commentary
on the state that we were in
people building in DeFi.
Again, this was middle of 2020.
It's been now four or five
months into the pandemic.
It was just kind of craziness
and this tweet just took off and
spread virally and everyone was
retweeting it.
I started getting messages hey,
is this on GitHub?
Can I fork this?
Can I use this?
A lot of people wanted to build
their own DeFi protocol and I'm
like no, it's not real, it's
just a joke.
But it was really getting
attention and I made the
decision probably about 45
minutes in after the tweet.
I got to do something with this
.
I got to continue this momentum
and what you did back then is
you started a telegram group.
So I started a telegram group
for the degenerator and there
was a bunch of people that just
jumped in and it was like OK,
what do we do now, I don't know.
And someone had the idea of
launching a token called the
degenerator token, because
that's what you did.
You launch a shit coin or
whatever, and at least that's
what some people do.
One thing led to another and
someone created this token and
they're like well, degenerator
is weird, it's only for people
that got the joke on Twitter.
Let's call it something
different.
So we took a vote.
I didn't have to call it meme
Because the whole point was like
I had created this meme.
So someone actually wrote a
contract and distributed tokens
to all the early telegram
members I believe there were
like 80 people or so in this
channel distributed.
We're getting to NFTs
eventually, don't worry.
No, I'm loving this dude.
This is great.
This meme token no utility at
all.
It was really just for fun.
Hey, let's do an airdrop Maybe.
I just thought it was all kind
of in fun.
Other people had the idea of
pumping it and doing a pump and
dump thing and that worried me a
little bit.
But so this token gets
distributed to 80 people.
I think it was 355 tokens per
person and then someone created
a tokenized using Collabland I
think we were one of the first
Collabland users First
Collabland is back in mid-2020.
One of the first and created a
separate telegram channel that
was token gated to the meme
token.
You had to hold a certain
number and that really kind of
helped spur it along as well.
But now there's a token and all
of a sudden it's like well, we
need to get our token onto
CoinGecko, so someone would
reach out to their friend on
CoinGecko and get the token
listed.
And then someone would be like
oh, we need to create liquidity
pool in Uniswap, so someone
would go do that.
It was this really weird.
It was like a microcosm for
crypto at large of like Wild
People just kind of coming
together.
Oh, I know this guy, I'll
message him.
Or I know this Totally.
Like watching it unfold.
I, just two hours before I had
made a stupid tweet on Twitter
Friday night it was probably
like 10 PM my time and this
thing was creating itself.
It was like had a mind of its
own and it was really insane and
some people were like shilling
it to others oh, this is
launched by Jordan Lyle,
consensus.
I was like, oh crap, this could
end badly.
Why are you through dumps and
dumps and everyone hates me.
My, I'm doxxed, everyone knows
who I am.
Like I don't want consensus to
get mad if somehow this goes the
wrong direction because I'm
attached to them.
So I end up just like trying to
distance myself and I'm like,
well, maybe that's not the right
thing to do.
What do I do?
I build products.
Why don't we give the token
some utility?
So there was a group of us and
we're just kind of putting our
heads together Like it'd be cool
to build something where we
actually created utility for
this token rather than it being
just a total shit coin, right,
right, we had a lot of ideas
Maybe it's doge for DeFi, where,
like, primarily it's a meme
coin, but like maybe it does
some other things and you can
stake it.
And we were just thinking, okay
, what are what's cool, what's
memeable these days?
As mentioned, you know, it was
DeFi Stummer.
So everyone was staking tokens
and trying to farm tokens and
NFTs just started getting
interesting again.
It was in the year 2020.
Couple projects that were like,
oh, this could be interesting,
this could be cool.
You know, quick, quick
backstory of like, what got me
into Ethereum in 2017 was
CryptoKitties.
So, like, that's my entrance
into the whole space is NFTs.
I met a mask so that I could
get some kitties, and I knew all
about punks.
I knew all about punks, but
it's like man, these kitties,
these are cool because you could
breed them and I just you know,
then you get so many different
variations and the art is cool.
So I went, I went that path.
So, like I had always kind of
kept my eye on NFTs and what was
going on with one of one sales
and other kind of like those,
those, you know, those those
gamified types of CryptoKitties
projects and stuff.
But then it hit us of like, wow,
what if you could actually farm
for NFTs?
So again, this is, you know,
middle of the night on a Friday
in August of 2020.
What if you could stake meme
tokens and earn points?
We ended up calling them
pineapple points because that
was emoji.
I happened to choose the
pineapple.
What if you could earn?
If you can earn pineapple
points and then redeem those
pineapple points, exchange them
for NFTs.
So we hired this is like in the
course of a weekend, we hired
an artist to create a bunch of
like meme NFTs little little
silly cartoons and a week later
so from the tweet to deploying
the project, I think was like 10
days, wow and worked with these
really cool developers and
designers, eric and Chris, who
became, you know, my partners in
crime there launched this the
meme platform V1, at the end of
August of 2020.
And the whole idea was pretty
straightforward.
You know, it was like man, you
don't need to have a bunch of
ETH to get NFTs.
Like you don't need to be an
ETH whale to mint NFTs.
What you need is you need to
put in the work.
So it's almost like proof of
work.
It was totally you stake token
and you come back at the right
time, then you're able to mint.
You have enough points, then
you're able to mint these things
and there are different levels
of rarity, and then, a couple of
weeks after that, we're said
well, there's something
interesting here.
A lot of people are taking
notice.
Why don't we work with real
artists?
And, you know, put a spin on it
and make it more about the art.
So we worked, you know, at the
end of 2020, we worked with some
really great artists Fo Woshes
was one of our original artists.
Incredible Jonathan Wolfe A
bunch of really great big comic
art.
A bunch of really cool artists
that have gone on to do some
really amazing work.
But it was just like man.
There needs to be an easier way
to collect or make collecting
fun.
It was a weird situation now
where we have this token and
this token is pumping because
you need to get in order to get
the art and NFTs are starting to
pick up again, so it was like
there was high demand to get
this token.
At one point this token was in
the top 100 of CoinGecko.
Wow, the airdrop.
If you had, most people had
sold.
I sold a bit, but if you had
held the airdrop and sold at its
pico top, it would have been a
million-dollar airdrop.
Wow, some people got a lot of
money.
I rode it all the way back down
, but it was insane.
Like there's so many more
stories in there that would be
cool to write an article or
something, but it was early.
Like PFPs weren't even a thing
by that point.
They were like a year old,
right.
So it was interesting how the
community responds to this idea
and we all want this thing to
grow.
Some are okay pumping it and
hurting others.
Others are interested in
preserving the reputation.
So this is still 2020.
So this is like Top Shot was
brand new, right, I bought brand
new.
So I really became.
I got deep into this space as a
builder, as someone who was
excited about working with
artists.
The past the previous few years,
was about crypto and DeFi and
the tech side of it.
So now it was like wow, there's
a real reason why this tech
exists and we're actually
providing a utility to artists.
We're helping artists earn a
living.
Up until now, you can't really
sell your digital art, but now
digital artists are able to earn
an income off my little
platform.
That started out as a joke like
literally started out as a joke
.
So we're at this weird thing
where this token is pumping and
what do we do?
Because we just airdropped it
to everybody.
We didn't have a developer fund
, we didn't have a team holding
any tokens, so the business
model was really really weird.
It was completely opposite of
what you'd normally do.
We did meme first and then the
token and then the product.
Usually you do it the other way
, but one thing led to another
and we essentially kind of sold
off the tech to a new company
and handed over the existing
platform to the community.
Unfortunately, that didn't go
very well and the community, or
certain community members, one
in particular kind of ran into
the ground, but we were able to
parlay it into a new company
called Nifty's that I ended up
co-founding.
But those few months of
literally nothing to creating
something in a short amount of
time, it was unlike anything
else.
The friends that I made during
that time, the experiences
gained I guess like the
notoriety of the following that
I was then given on Twitter
trying to navigate my day job at
Consensus and how do I make
this NFT thing full-time.
It was a wild second half of
2020 and early 21.
It was insane, man, and that
just there's a lot we can dive
into there.
But that really it lit the fire
of like, wow, this tech, when
used for the right reasons, can
do some really special things
and helping artists, creating a
collecting experience that is
communal and fun.
As you can imagine, as we now
think of prohibition, those are
common threads, right?
Yeah, totally.
You can certainly think about
that until later, but like,
that's kind of always been the
vibe you know.
Speaker 1: The through line
Crazy.
Yeah, yeah, dude, I mean I
think just the best part about,
I mean, my first takeaway of
that and, before I say it, thank
you for like going really deep
into that man, because I came in
early 2021.
No, dude.
Well, that's why we do a
podcast.
Very good, that's why it's
Listeners.
Speaker 2: feel free to skip
ahead.
Speaker 1: I don't know if I'll
hold it against you.
That's why it exists, though,
but I think that a lot of people
though including myself,
because I came in in 2021, so
before that to me is kind of
like just this mystical land
that existed well before I came
in.
I knew about crypto, all I knew
about crypto.
I didn't have anything against
it, but I was just one of those
people of I wasn't at the point
where I was super curious about
it.
I wasn't really in a curious
stage of my life yet, and I just
saw the number pumping.
I'm like, okay, but what do I
spend it on?
Like, why is this valuable?
You know, like to me, the way I
think about things is like
until I can spend it on
something, it to me, is useless.
You know what I mean?
Like I wasn't fully in my
investor mindset.
I didn't understand store value
.
I didn't understand.
I just didn't understand any of
the things that I now have a
better grasp on today, that I'm
still learning on, so I kind of
just watched it happen.
So these stories are incredible
, and it reminds me of a lot of
the reasons why I came here and
some of the same feelings that
you mentioned of like something,
like things just happened from
nothing.
I think what really is super
magical about the story is that
people just randomly wanted to
support it for, I guess, for the
cause, you know what I mean
Like there's this, like the
cause, or like you know, and I
think that's different with each
project, but I think it's
really fascinating to watch
something that came from a, from
what you call a stupid tweet
and it may have been, you know,
but I think that's the.
I'm going all over the place,
but the one of my favorite parts
is that I judge myself so heavy
for some tweets, you know, or
just like you know, that's just
going to be a dumb idea, that's
going to be a dud, you know, or
that's just going to be, but you
just never know.
Like, you just absolutely never
know, like what can happen as a
result of like kind of
following that childlike
intuition, if you will, you know
, and just kind of letting
letting something run for the
sake of letting it run and
seeing a bunch of people form
around it, because your stories
or that's that one story, I'm
sure you have many more.
Those were some of the very
similar things that happened to
me when I came in in early 2021
about, like why this thing was
valuable, like what was so fun
about it?
It's these like I don't know
man, it's just super wholesome,
I guess, is the right word to
use.
You know yeah.
Speaker 2: I think we're all
just trying to like recreate
those experiences, right, and it
takes a few more cycles for
some people Like I mean, there
are a lot of opportunities that
I missed just because I didn't
get it.
But like training your mind of,
like setting aside what's, you
know what sounds reasonable, and
like suspend this belief a
little bit.
Okay, I can, I can see why some
people might find this valuable
, but for some people like you,
need to be hit over the head
Because it's, it's weird, it's
it's so, it's so different from,
from what a lot of people are,
you know, conditioned to to
think.
Speaker 1: And I think it's
really interesting how you, you
know, building products here is
the the meme comes first and
then the product comes last.
It's a very counterintuitive
way to to think about things.
You know.
It's like typically, people
have to build a product in the
current I guess for lack of a
better term, just because I'm
lazy right now like in the
traditional way of building
businesses and web.
Two is that you have to have a
product before the memes can
exist.
But I don't know, I but I.
But I also know that I think
about that.
Some of some of my favorite
brands started from like my like
, where I buy my beard product.
That started as like a, a
memeable men's blog.
You know what I mean, and it's
like.
It started about one dude, you
know, just blogging about beard
oil.
You know what I mean Like, and
so you know, and then products
came from that later.
So it's kind of it's kind of an
interesting model.
Speaker 2: But so you know, all
over the place it's like I mean,
that's the creator model and
like ticked, tickers, put out a
con, put out content, create
their own brand and then begin
selling their own products.
So I think that's that's where
we're at and I think it's it's
all storytelling, right?
That's why I really love
branding and like creating a
product and creating a community
, and it all starts with the
idea first and the meme first.
So, yeah, even getting into
prohibition, it was like I don't
want it to be XYZ chain or XYZ
platform or whatever.
Like there needs to be a story,
I need to get behind it Totally
, and so that's that's what's
some of the most fun time.
Product building is just like
coming up with, with the
narratives you know.
Speaker 1: Do you think you
could ever go back to building
products, not in crypto?
Speaker 2: I don't think so.
It doesn't move quick enough.
It doesn't.
The stakes aren't as high.
I can't imagine doing something
outside of like crypto maybe,
maybe IAI or space or something
like that.
Where it is, there's so much
unknown, still yet to be like
invented, but yeah, I can't
imagine not having this.
You know, this type of industry
that just evolves so quickly.
Speaker 1: Totally dude.
I feel the same way and I was
very curious from like a super,
from a product builders
perspective, because it just it
seems like once you cross the
chasm, like there's this like
point of no return, where it's
just there's, it just doesn't
make sense and I feel that the
and I this may sound real
nebulous, but kind of like the
way I've been thinking about
things like you look at products
like phones, for example.
Like you look at how small the
innovation is on iPhones now.
Like you look at like the gap
between the 14 and the 15.
And there's just it's not much,
you know.
Like we essentially buy phones
because the batteries in the old
ones we were on Twitter way too
often, you know and and they
just destroys our battery and
that's the reason why we're
buying new one.
Speaker 2: But I feel like every
year, just for context, like
I'm stupid and probably paying
more than I need to, but I have.
I have the plan where I can get
a new one every year is because
, even though it's not a minor
upgrade, I like having them, the
cool new gadget, you know dude,
I'm the same way.
Speaker 1: This was the first
time since.
So I I bought the first one up
to the five, like I was an every
year iPhone guy up to the five,
then, kind of like, in my
opinion, the six to the nine,
for the meme that it was, that
it was not.
It was probably the worst in my
opinion, the worst couple years
of iPhone models, because it
was just there wasn't, there
wasn't anything fun, there
wasn't anything exciting like
the there was.
You know, in the first five
iPhones there was some really
incremental shifts between
between models and it was really
enticing to spend that.
So I went to camp galaxy and
Google phone.
For, like you know, I had, like
the, the galaxy SA, and then I
had the galaxy note and then I
had the Google phone and then I
came back to Apple.
I had to take that left curve,
like that left turn, you know,
because it was just I couldn't
get behind it.
But I'm, it's nice to hear.
So I say that this is the first
time I actually had the iPhone
13.
Before I just bought the 15 pro
or the pro max.
This is the first year where I
actually had two years in
between phone models and I like
I'm like really proud of myself
for that, because I'm typically
like you, I'm an every year kind
of guy and I probably spend way
too much money on like one
minor, like hardware upgrade or
like a slightly better battery.
But it just to me, you know,
even when it comes to like you
know some of these like kind of
bootleg service providers where
you can like watch unlimited
sports, it's like yeah, but the
voice is slightly off, or like
you can't watch it on your phone
, or you can't like there's the,
the, the.
It's worth paying the full
experience, or like paying for
it.
For the full experience, in my
opinion, and that's how they get
us, is that that, that
composability, I guess?
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's it.
And just like we're getting
older and like we don't want to
go to that.
So it was like pirating
software anymore.
Now you just paid 40 bucks a
month and you get access to
Photoshop and all the other apps
.
And it's interesting how, yeah,
the things we did back then and
how things change, and I don't
even you know.
Back to the phone, it's like,
well, now I can get a 5x
telephoto lens.
Like, yeah, I kind of want that
.
It doesn't make sense.
Hey, however much you know the
plans where you pay per month
just so you can upgrade at the
end of the year, it's, it's,
it's not too bad, but it's like
now my, my, both my kids have
phones, but I don't want them to
get a new one every year.
So I'm trying to like balance
out my own tech addiction with,
like trying to be a good example
here.
It's interesting.
Speaker 1: I was about to say
every.
You know that's a.
I had a.
I think I have a question on
that is that you know it's.
It's always interesting when I,
when I give advice to other
people, I always uncover the,
the hypocrisy within myself of
like you know, like, wow, I'm
not doing anything of what I
just said you know, and how can
I just, how can I teach someone
to do, to like form good habits,
when mine are horrendous?
You know, um, yeah, um, curious
what you're like as it, because
here's so I, when I got into
crypto, like I'm, like I'm a
single dude and it's real easy
because my only responsibility
is a dog.
You know you're a parent.
You know you have a wife, you
have a family.
What do you like?
What do they think about all of
this?
Like this, like appetite for
this kind of like high risk
tolerance, like risk tolerant
industry, or this, uh, this new
found, I guess, frontier, do
they?
Are they like fully supportive
of it?
Do they?
Do they question your sanity
often, do they?
I'm very curious to understand
this.
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think it's.
It's been a process for my wife
.
Um, my kids were kind of born
into it, so they know, know
nothing else.
Like I've always, even before
crypto, I was doing stupid web
and mobile app ideas and, uh, I
mean we didn't even get into it.
But like I made an app that
lets you talk to Santa Claus, uh
, 10 years ago and like, uh, we
were, we were all you know.
So my kids got to be beta
testers this app and they got to
talk to Santa and like, I've
always been just like doing
weird stuff, weird apps, and I I
try to build the things that I
think are cool, uh, and
sometimes there's a market for
them, um, so I think that
they're, they're, they've kind
of been conditioned, they know,
they know nothing else.
Where I don't have, you know, a
normal nine to five, I haven't
since they've been really little
and um, but my wife, uh, she is
very supportive, um, she's been
along for the ride.
She puts up a good front.
Sometimes it it's, uh, it's.
You know, I've we've moved
around a lot.
We've, uh, we've kind of been,
uh, you know, operating without
a safety net.
Sometimes in the previous years,
with different entrepreneurial
ventures, she's been a trooper,
um, but it's, it's tough
sometimes, you know, um, yeah,
and she'll even tell the story
of like, uh, hey, uh, I I got, I
got a job in crypto and we're
going full-time crypto and she's
, and she, she would be like,
well, I know that's kind of been
your hobby, but I didn't, I
didn't realize you could
actually make a career out of it
.
So, you know, for the last six
years now, being full-time in
crypto, um, I think she's
starting to come around.
She's.
I mean you, you met her in in
Marfa and she, she came to Marfa
and I mean she went to events
even without me.
I was in, I was in bed, and she
went and and partied.
Uh, she is, um, it's not her
second nature to be on, you know
, as tech curious as we all are,
Uh, but she loves the community
, loves the people.
I think she just now, after
Marfa, got the whole uh idea
around, like generative art and
what, what that's all about, um,
so it was kind of fun to bring
them along on the journey, but
it it, like you know, like we've
been saying, it just takes
people, uh, you know it's, for
some people it's a, it's a, it's
a harder, uh, more uphill
battle, you know.
Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah, totally,
I, I, I just my hat's off to, to
the dads and the, and the
husbands and the wives and the,
the people with significant
others, because I feel like, I
feel like, in a way, it probably
keeps you grounded in a sense
you know of, like, you know to
make sure your head doesn't get
too far up in the clouds, uh,
you know to to to have a sense
of reality.
But, um, I think it's a really,
I think it's a really
interesting concept.
I just think, like man, like,
even just talking to my parents
about this, I have to really
water it down to its simplest
form to try to tell them what
I'm doing on a daily basis.
And it wasn't until they saw
results of like, I made a good
flip and I covered some of my
debt.
They were like, okay, like,
maybe we'll start paying
attention to this because you
got something for free, you
flipped it for 25 grand and you
made a smart financial decision
with that 25 grand.
Like, maybe we'll start paying
attention.
Yeah, it's a trip.
Speaker 2: Yeah, I know everyone
has those types of stories and
it is difficult and I think
there is for the parents out
there.
I don't know, we should
probably wear that as a PFP or
have some sort of badge on
Twitter, because it's when you
meet other parents on or in this
space, it's like, okay, extra
respect, because it is difficult
to.
I mean, the nature of this
business makes you kind of be
online and present a lot more
often than you would like to,
and that's a challenge for
myself and a lot of others is
finding time to disconnect.
But part of what makes us
successful in this space is by
being in the know and knowing
what's going on and being
opportunistic and shipping early
and making these right
decisions and making these
friends and networking
opportunities.
So unless you're active, it's
hard to, it's hard to bring
value and receive value in this
space.
So now we're in a startup and
it's a crypto startup, and so
it's like stacking all these
things stacking up against you
and now that like you have to,
not have to, but you want to
spend time with your family.
So it's like how do you get
this all in?
How do you stay on top of new
tokens or new NFT projects, and
that's kind of why I like the
bear market in general Totally.
It's because you don't have to
be on top of everything
necessarily.
You can kind of, even though
there is some, there is still a
baseline of knowledge that you
have to get every day.
There's still like you can
spend more time building.
So, yeah, that's.
I don't know how I do it.
I'm thankful that my kids still
know who I am.
I try to schedule it, put it in
my calendar, and my kids are
getting older now, so it's try
to just spend as much time with
them as I can Do they take an
interest in what you do.
Speaker 1: I think, to a certain
extent, my daughter is artistic
.
Speaker 2: She's a dancer, she
likes to draw, so she kind of
resonates with some of the art
side.
My son is a gamer and a tech
junkie as well, so he gets you
know that kind of stuff.
You know the NFT stuff.
He gets digital value because
you know he's spending or at
least in the past he spent a lot
of money on Fortnite skins and
things and V-Bucks and like the
whole the digital money concept
was not a big.
He's already dealing with
digital money right Now, totally
, you know.
So it wasn't that big a deal of
like.
Okay, imagine you can take
V-Bucks to another game, or
imagine you can take that
shotgun to the next popular game
.
So that was not too much of a
lead for them.
I think they just get it.
Everything is digital.
Like you know, their allowance
is through an app and so it's
just gonna be.
I mean, it's just a matter of
time until we get the old people
out of here and the new, the
newcomers, the next generation.
It's just gonna be obvious.
So it's just a matter of time
till mass adoption.
Speaker 1: Totally dude.
So let me ask you what do you
think?
There's a couple more questions
I have, but one thing that just
sparked is, you know, we talk
about mass adoption and we talk
about, like, what that's gonna
look like, and everyone tries to
predict the future.
And you know, back in like 2020
, you know 2020, we had this
kind of like rumbling in art,
you know, and then you had Nifty
Gateway and then you had our
like our blocks was definitely
around, but I feel like it that
you know, summer of 2021, it
just like, well, then you had
the Beeple sale and then you had
, you know, board apes, and then
you had V-Friends, and then you
had just massive mania of our
blocks, you know.
So do you think that, like, I
guess it follows the same
patterns as before?
Do you see some of those same
patterns like emerging, do you?
I guess, where I always you
know where I'm kind of like
tripped up, is that?
Or I guess not tripped up, but
I'm just like, okay, pfcs were
fun.
You know, art is clearly, you
know, has and always will be the
play for most things, but I
just feel like we're at the spot
where it's like, okay, pfcs are
dead.
What's it gonna take Is the
simple question.
Speaker 2: Yeah, you know, after
having been through, you know
now, a decade of my crypto
journey, seeing ups and downs
and seeing certain things take
off and then fall back down.
There's a lot of junk out there
, there's a lot of crap out
there, but it would have been a
dumb move to totally ignore
Bitcoin after it first crashed
right, or Ethereum after it
first crashed, or, you know,
when NFTs came around.
It would have been a bad move
to lose focus on DeFi.
I think I liken it to like the
earlycom bubble of like
everything on the internet
crashed hard, but that's when
you know Amazon was built,
that's when PayPal was built,
that's when you know
app-arromated resurgence.
So if you were ignoring tech
completely, then you totally
missed the boat.
So for me, it's like okay, what
are the things of value in the
last few years that we can pull
out?
And it's still really hard to
not fomo into projects and to
like make assumptions and to
attribute past success to future
success.
It's really hard to like take
the emotions out of it, and I'm
guilty of like doing a bunch of
stupid stuff and selling things
at the wrong time and holding
onto things when I shouldn't.
But each wave like you learn a
little bit more and you learn
about how the market works,
about how humans work, how you
yourself work, how you think and
how you have to kind of protect
yourself from getting too
excited, getting too high,
getting too low.
So you start to build up this
kind of tolerance or this kind
of like protection or framework
for yourself.
I feel so strongly for Bitcoin
and Ethereum.
I think there are gonna be a
lot of other chains and tokens
that find favor, but I just know
that those two platforms aren't
going anywhere.
I owned a bunch of NFTs over
the year.
I still do.
It would have been millions of
dollars that I sold at the high.
I did okay, but definitely made
some really bad decisions and
not holding onto things and
selling things at the wrong time
.
So it's maybe human nature to
think, okay, what's gonna be the
next thing that pops?
I think part of it is being
open to those types of things
and maybe it's gaming, maybe
it's VR related, maybe it's
social tokens or whatever.
So what I try to do is just be
aware of what's going on, try to
pull out some like mental
models of the past few years,
try to find the common threads
here, be curious and
experimental, but don't go too
crazy.
Where you're risking money you
can't lose.
I think what we've seen I think
DeFi's gonna be around it wasn't
just some flash in the pan.
Like to create a financial
infrastructure without a
middleman that allows anyone to
get a loan if they've got the
collateral, like that's
something that needs to exist
right, totally, when we think a
few years out, art is something
that's going to need to exist
forever, right.
We think about first principles
and one of the things that
people have been doing for
centuries, millennia, is being
around art and creating art in
one form or another.
So it makes sense that, like,
of course the art is digital, of
course the art uses a
blockchain which allows us to
trustlessly trade it and secure
it and fractionalize it and
financialize it.
Everything becomes natively
digital of course our money, of
course our financial
infrastructure, of course these
digital assets, of course art,
collectibles, gaming assets.
So it's like just trying to
find those things that you know
that you have conviction in and
moving forward.
So it's really hard to kind of
take a guess on what's next, but
I know, like some of the things
, that when I look back, some of
the things that stand out,
that's why I'm making a bigger
bet on art.
I think it's more than just
like, oh, if you're an artist in
web two, you're gonna become an
artist in web three, or if
you're a painter, you're gonna
become a digital artist.
I think it's more than just the
one-to-one kind of skeuomorphic
model here.
I think so many more people are
gonna become through this
technology, are gonna become
interested in art, and so many
of us had maybe a passing
interest, but it wasn't really
until NFTs and, for many of us,
generative art, where it finally
clicked and we're something
that we're really excited about
and spend a lot of money on.
So I think it's gonna be this
Cambrian explosion.
It's gonna be.
It's really gonna level up just
the amount of people that care
about art, that think about art,
that create art.
I think there's not a lot of
people consider themselves
artists.
I mean, it's a simple, maybe
silly example, but I've never
considered myself an artist.
I always had a sense for design
.
I feel like I have a good eye,
always thinking about it in
terms of a product sense and
good usability, good design of a
product.
But several months ago I
launched my own art collection.
It just goes to show that, like
I think there's untapped
creativity, untapped artistry,
that it used to be scratch on a
cave wall and then it became
paint brushes, and then it
became a camera, and then it
then becoming code, and then
they're all kind of merging
together to create new forms
that we haven't thought about.
So I think more people should
consider themselves artists and
I'm just very bullish on
generative art, digital art and
that really being a thing that
brings in a lot of people to
this web three world.
I know that by thinking about
that, I'm probably missing out.
On gaming or by social or
whatever.
I have a tendency to like try
to do a bunch of different
things at once and like always
moving on to the next shiny
object.
So in launching prohibition
it's like okay, what are the
things?
Now that I have been in this
space for a long time, what are
the things I know are true and
have a strong belief in?
And I think we're just barely
scratching the surface in terms
of generative art, in terms of
digital art via NFTs.
So that's where I've just
placed my time, you know.
Speaker 1: I yeah, I mean, I
feel like we have a lot of
similarities in that sense of I
mean, I never considered myself
even just a step further back in
art collector.
You know, this is a whole.
I think what this has done is
transformed, or it's opened the
door to a lot of people to start
exploring what is collecting
art even mean.
How does it make me feel?
What's my role in this?
And I think to your point,
though, and I think prohibitions
played a really big role in
this, and there's a question at
the end of this that I'm excited
to ask you, but it's like I
think what's really cool to
reflect on is that, just like
what you said, because when I
talk to my mom about generative
art, she's like well, it's code.
She's like there's this
disconnect between art and code.
There's this it can't be code.
She's like I don't think of
people that the coders that I
worked with.
I don't consider them artists,
but it's like, okay, but what if
they could be?
What if that could exist?
And something that I think and I
wrote this in that tweet a week
or so ago I think one of my
most favorite things about like
the idea that you brought with
prohibition is the matchmaking
concept, because I think it's
been really cool to see.
The first example that comes to
mind, obviously, is Ed Balloon.
Of him, he is not a coder, but
he found a coder with an
artistic vision, or he was able
to take his artistic vision,
combine that with code and make
something completely unique, and
I think that I think to me that
is like that's something that
excited me when we first started
working together and then it's
still exciting to this very day.
I think that's the limitless
potential of this is that
there's a lot of curiosity now,
and I think what you guys have
done is like open the doors to a
whole new level of art form and
that it yeah and I don't even
know what that's called it could
just be called matchmaking, it
could just be called generative
art, but I think it's a really
interesting thing.
So the question I have is it's
a really roundabout way of
asking this is if you could have
a collab, if you could have
your dream matchmaking scenario.
Which like what two, like what
artists would you wanna see with
a?
Like, if you have a specific
coder in mind, with a certain
artist in mind, like what would
be your ideal matchmaking?
Speaker 2: Oh man.
Well, the question was who do I
see myself collaborating with,
like the dream collaborator
matchup with me?
Yeah, I wouldn't.
I would be able to point to the
thing I just launched, which is
Heart and Craft with Snotro.
I mean, never in a million
years did I think I'd be able to
collaborate with the creator of
this Chromie Squiggle.
Like, I'm still, you know,
pinching myself thinking about
that.
Like that was just such an
amazing opportunity.
But it speaks to the larger
vision of like collaboration
that we're trying to push
forward at prohibition.
When I think about like dream
matchups of other people, I
would love to see more, just
like I've done this.
Like without, without Jalil,
without Jalil, there's no Jack
Butcher, right?
Jack Butcher has like amazing
skills on his own.
He has amazing vision, artistic
vision, he's got something to
say, but without Jalil writing
the smart contracts, then it
wouldn't mean as much as his
projects mean today.
So, even if, like, I just think
there's so many projects yet to
be released that have this
built-in component, whether it's
generative art or not, like now
it's interactive, now it's
composable, now it's now you can
actually, you know, experience
your art in a new way, and it's
stuff that requires developers.
So, yeah, more than just
generative stuff.
It's like developers are now
becoming part of the thing,
which is really exciting.
I work with a couple of
developers on my team Thomas
Dory and I would love to see
them work with an artist and
collab on some things.
They're amazing developers on
their own visual as well, but,
like, pairing them up with an
artist would be really fun.
They're busy because they're
building a platform, but that
would be fun.
You guys mentioned, you know
I've been working with artists
since 2020 and I have kind of
developed my own kind of list of
favorite artists.
So I'm actually reaching out to
many of them, trying to like,
pick their brain and plant a
seed of like what have you
always wanted to do that
requires coding, or what's a
dream generative collection that
you would want to see?
So, yeah, it's a lot of these
artists that haven't yet you
know that are doing.
One of ones I'm a big fan of
Jonathan Wolfe, big fan of Brian
Brinkman.
He's done generative, course,
but those unique styles
Fawocious.
I would love to see some of
those types of artists that I've
been friends with for the past
couple of years that have, like,
their unique style.
I'd love to see what, like, put
them in a room with a next
level developer and what do we
get?
Totally, I love these.
I just think, like mashing up
these different forms of media
is super interesting, right,
like music videos are
interesting because you get the
music and the visual, and now we
have generative art that also
has music.
Like just mixing all these
things has been super fun, or
making it interactive, you know,
stepping inside it.
And I'm excited about the
future of like AR and VR, of
like, yeah, your NFT maybe it's
the still frame version, but
like there's so much more than
what you see up front and it
actually represents something
that you can, you know, step
into a world that you can live
in.
Yeah, I'm just really excited
to see what's to come, and I
don't think we're ready for it.
I don't think our brains are
even ready to see what's next,
dude?
Speaker 1: yeah, I mean there's
a lot.
Yeah, there's a lot, you know,
I think we're just, I think
we're at the early stage and I
think you guys are definitely
people that spearheaded that or
pioneered that idea, that
concept, and it's got to feel
really cool.
You know, and I'd be remiss to
not talk about, you know, heart
and craft a little bit here
before we start wrapping things
up.
But I think the real quick,
before I go to that, is that I
think that this interesting
mixup of generative art is
something that you just said.
That made me think a little bit
is that.
I mean you look at as high of a
level example as TikTok, you
know, like the best content is
mashups.
It's taking one piece of
content and adding commentary on
top of it, or doing a duet,
sing along, or, like you know,
singing along, maybe not live,
or like finding some funny way
to add value or add an
additional commentary to what
was already created.
And I feel like this is that,
but with generative art.
Like I feel like this is that,
but with fine art, you know what
I mean.
It feels like there's this
really cool thing that's
happening where.
It's like this is that, but
with more established art, I
guess, is the way to say that,
yeah, yeah, and it's really
great dude.
Speaker 2: Peanut butter and
chocolate is better than peanut
butter or chocolate, like the
two things together.
Just, you know, just thinking
about the art and craft project,
it turned out to be so much
better than I had envisioned, so
much better than Snowfrog had
envisioned.
But it's me kind of bringing my
product sensibility and my you
know, my, my own approach and my
own taste to the project.
And then, of course, him taking
it a mile further with his
color, you know, with what's
going on in his brain when it
comes to color theory, and just
his experience with squiggles
and him being able to create
these gradients just from his
head, and it he'll say the same
thing Like, working together,
putting two heads together,
you're able to take it to a
place that, like it shouldn't be
this good, you know, like I
mean, it's just a spirit of,
like, collaboration and
composability gets the word gets
thrown around a lot, especially
when it comes to DeFi, because
we're building, like these open
source money Legos is what we
used to say in DeFi where it's
like, okay, you're going to
build this concept of USDC, so
I'm going to go over here and
build a lending platform, and
then, oh, if you want a lending
platform, you're going to need
this and really it's.
It's been really cool to see
open source software just kind
of build on itself.
And the same thing goes with,
like creative endeavors of like
two people from different walks
of life, two people from
different you know just ways of
thinking and different skill
sets.
They're able to put their heads
together and create something
magical.
Yeah, so it's something that
we're thinking a lot about.
Of course, there are some
people out there that are just
geniuses on their own.
Like Tyler Hobbs doesn't need
to be working with anybody,
right, like he is just, you know
, he's the unicorn.
But for a lot of us, I think we
should be exploring the
collaborations.
We've seen a lot of collabs in
the past, many collabs in
generative art.
Like the developer goes unnamed
and that's okay.
That's fine too if that's the
arrangement.
But I think we need to start
calling out like all the parties
involved and you know we're
able to do that and split the
contract and make sure everybody
gets paid.
But it's really cool that like,
okay, we're going to give the
guy who came up with the idea
he's going to get a percentage
of the take, and then the person
who was, like the creative
director, they're going to get a
slice of the pie the person who
did the music.
They're going to get a slice of
the pie.
Someone who did the sound
effects.
You know, it's going to be
really cool to like see more and
more artists building off of
each other.
One thing that we haven't really
scratched yet we've been
thinking about for a long time
is remixing and remix culture.
Imagine you create something,
you market a CCO.
I take your work and I build on
top of it.
Maybe create my own spin.
If someone goes and buys my NFT
downstream, you'll get paid
because I used your STEM or
whatever you want to call it
right?
Yeah, it would be cool to think
like building off of each other
, like actually making part of
that, like the flywheel, and
like building it into the
platform.
So, yeah, again, I just think
we're really early here, as we
always say, and it's going to be
so fun to watch.
Speaker 1: Yeah, dude, I mean
that's a.
You've introduced a lot of new
concepts.
I mean the, because that's the
current.
I guess you could.
There's a lot of issues around
new media and copyright, and you
know what's.
You know what's copying, what's
not, and I think this is a
great use case to try to for
lack of a better term fuck
around and find out.
You know, it just makes sense
because people are doing it
anyway.
You know it's like it's
oftentimes, you know the what's
really fascinating and I'm just
going to take a small tangent
and come back to this for a
minute but you look at, like CSO
, like which is, you know,
counter-strike is one of the
largest esports you know and you
look at these trading platforms
like they're going to find a
way to trade skins anyway.
You know so, like why not give
people an actual, equitable and
trustless way to do it?
You know what I mean, which,
just as a side note, just
constantly blows my mind like
why a lot of people in the
gaming world are still against
it.
It's like we're not trying to
change the system, we're just
trying to make it better so you
don't get fucked over, so you
don't get like, so nothing bad
happens, right, cause I think
there was a.
There was just another massive
sale six figure sale for a
Counter-Strike weapons game, you
know, which is absolutely mind
boggling.
But I think that I'm excited to
watch what you guys, what you
guys do here.
You know, I think it's a really
it's a fun idea and I'm glad
that we're involved with it in
some way, shape or form.
You know, it's been a treat to
be alongside for the ride.
But one thing that actually you
actually inspired me in Marfa
to, because there was a, you
know, dmitri Triniot released
his like an iterations of the
ringer for LACMA.
And I got the email and I was
like I don't need it, like I
don't need it.
And you know, then I saw like
okay, it came with an 1155 NFT,
while it's not, you know,
directly tied to it, still kind
of cool, but I was still like,
you know, probably not going to
do it.
Just, yeah, I'm not sure Love
the LACMA.
But then I saw it in person and
I was like, wow, like okay.
And it wasn't just that, but
there was a talk that you gave
around your Fidenza, that you
have hanging up in your house
and that it's a conversation
piece.
And that was really when I saw
that and I have an exact place
where I'm going to hang it.
It's literally going to be like
right there and that's going to
be immediately seen when people
walk into it, because I think
it's a fascinating thing when
people look at it.
You just can't help but look at
it and wonder about it.
What have been?
You know.
So you inspired that ringer
because you were like the
Fidenza's a conversation piece.
What has been?
Is there a certain conversation
that comes to mind?
You know that you've had around
that Fidenza piece when people
have walked into your house.
Speaker 2: I just think it's
another way to.
I don't know.
I always try to think of, like,
how can I talk to my family,
how can I convince others and
show people like what I do and
what's going on, and like try to
copy over or transfer some of
the enthusiasm?
And it is so cool to have this?
I mean, you said a conversation
piece that you know when you
come in, it's right in the main
spot there and everyone sees it
and I think most people just
think it's oh, it's cool, Maybe
somebody painted it or somebody
used Photoshop, but I would say
nine times out of 10, that's
where it ends.
But there's, you know, 10% of
people that ask about it or show
interest or stop to stare at it
for a little while.
And that's like the icebreaker
for me, where I can just dive in
and start chatting.
It's always hard to know okay,
do I start talking to this
person?
How's that going to come off?
But anytime you have like
anyone shows any interest, right
then you jump on them.
That's what tends to be the
case.
So, yeah, even with my parents
and I've been talking to them
for years and years and years
around what I do and what I work
on and why I'm excited about
this stuff and how it's unique.
And you know my dad shows
interest and he, you know he
built his own kind of portfolio.
He's started to get his feet
wet, but it was really cool to
be able to say, see this, this
is actually a print.
This isn't the art.
The real art is, you know, it's
stored on chain and it wasn't
created like an artist didn't
set out to create this unique
thing.
They actually wrote the
algorithm and then the script
told the computer what to do and
it like randomly created this
outlet and so like to be able to
.
Now you're kind of red pilling,
so to speak, someone into
generative art and that gets
them into, like, why the
blockchain is helpful in that
you know in that process and how
it's stored.
And it's been really cool even
just for, you know, having my
kids be around it, my wife
encounter it and you know that's
just one example, Like a
million other pieces, some that
are just in this room.
That I think is starting to
like chip away, where I don't
have to be so intense about
trying to show off my passion,
that I can just kind of I can
put it out there and other
people can ask about it, but I
think it really is a great way
to like get people excited about
what's going on here.
Speaker 1: Totally dude.
Yeah, that definitely.
Yeah, I can't remember where
you said that, but it definitely
.
That was like what triggered
the purchase of that.
I was like that feels really
fun, you know.
Speaker 2: I'm excited for you
because I didn't even get that
thing, so that's going to be
awesome man.
Speaker 1: Yeah, dude, I'm
excited because it was really
funny, because it was the
through I read.
The only reason I knew about it
early was through the avant.
I registered for the avant art
rip cash drawing and I, you know
, unfortunately missed that and
they were like, hey, like we saw
, you missed out on this, but
you know, we're going to gauge
interest for this.
This is what's coming, you know
, yada, yada, yada.
We're going to just be
registering interest and we'll
be available for purchase until
this time.
But if you want to buy it
directly, you don't, you could
skip a couple steps and you get
to skip the line away.
I was like, all right, that's a
great, it was a great, it was a
great sales methodology there.
But I was, yeah, I'm so, I'm so
excited for it.
It's one of the things I'm most
excited to get delivered in the
mail, like out of everything
this year.
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's great
man.
I mean the ringer itself and
that whole collection and
algorithm.
It's probably onboarded more
people to generative art than
any other collection, maybe
minus squiggles or something
because it was really impactful
for me when I first saw it come
around and, of course, I didn't
acquire any, but it was a really
good example of like what's
possible is like, okay, here are
some pegs and then you
interrupt strings around the
pegs and you can actually get
that pretty easily.
But then it's like okay, look
at all the different outputs
that we can create from just
that common idea.
So it's so cool, it's like the
perfect conversation piece, as
you call it.
So that's exciting man.
Speaker 1: Yeah, dude, so it'll
be fun man.
But yeah, dude, so I guess want
to be conscious of your time
here, man.
I want to give you at least a
little bit of a break before
your next call.
This has been a lot of fun, man
.
I just want to really
appreciate you for your in-depth
answers and the time that
you've given.
It's been a treat to get to
know you a little bit better.
Speaker 2: Yeah, dude, always
cool to hang out.
I'm glad we got to do this deep
dive.
I would love to learn more
about you at some point as well.
I feel like I've taken center
stage here, but really
appreciate working with you and
your team.
Your team is amazing the team
at Schiller.
It's just been a blast working
with that group over these last
few months.
I mean, this is why we're in
this space.
There's a lot of code, there's
a lot of hype, there's a lot of
digital assets, there's a lot of
fluff, but at the end of the
day, it's like the people you
get to work with that keeps us
around.
It's just been great working
with you guys.
Yeah, thanks for the
opportunity to dive down a deep
hole there and tell a piece of
my story.
Man.
Speaker 1: Yeah, dude, I feel
like we barely scratched the
surface.
Man, I feel like an IRL three
and a half hour podcast is
warranted, because I think
there's just so much to tell man
.
Thanks for giving me a glimpse
and giving me a little bit more
of a window inside of yourself.
What makes you get up every day
?
Just the love for Genitive Art,
man.
It's been a lot of fun.
You give me a lot of new ideas
from a builder's perspective,
from an artist's perspective,
just a new perspective in
general.
Is there anything that you'd
want to shout out at the end or
anywhere where you want to point
people after this is over,
whether it's Twitter website, et
cetera, would love to give you
an opportunity to do that.
Speaker 2: Sure, yeah.
First thing I want to say is
that I'm the face of this thing
and a lot of the other projects
that I've built in my past don't
always have the time to thank
the team.
I just want to thank the
prohibition team Thomas and
Dorian and Jonathan and Tim and
Taylor and as long and Tom and
everyone that's involved, just
because without them there
wouldn't be prohibition.
It's been great to be able to
take credit from time to time as
the voice of this thing, but
this wouldn't even be a thing
without the incredible team
behind me.
Thanks for letting me sidebar a
little bit there.
I'm just really excited about
speaking of scratching the
surface.
We've barely gotten into all
the ideas that we have for
prohibition and how we want to
grow the community.
If you have any interest in
generative art, I would tell
people to check out prohibition.
We build in public and we want
to keep getting feedback and we
want to keep delivering value
for our collectors and creators.
If you're an artist and you
want a particular tool like,
jump into the Discord and let us
know.
We try to be very open and
transparent and listen to our
users.
If you're a generative artist
and you want some place new and
exciting and flexible and
experimental.
Come to prohibitionart.
Yeah, we're excited for what's
to come in 2024.
Speaker 1: Hell, yeah, man.
Well, jordan, thanks for adding
that in.
As I said, from a collector's
perspective, it's wonderful just
to see a lot of new ways in
which the artists are
experimenting on that platform.
Even the last plug of getting
to buy art with Apple Pay, that
was pretty dope.
That was a really fun
experience to be able to do that
.
This is as a testament, not
only while we do work together.
It's so much fun to use these,
regardless of whether we were
working together or not.
It's like we would be using
this platform and it's a lot of
fun.
Yeah, man, we'll go ahead and
wrap it up here.
Until next time, man, hang out
for a little bit just to let it
finish uploading.
Again, jordan, thank you so
much again for your time.
This has been a treat, man.
Speaker 2: Yeah, thanks again.
Thanks so much for having me.
This was awesome.
Speaker 1: Thank you for
listening to the Shiller Curated
Podcast.
We hope you enjoyed the
conversation.
As we close out today's episode
, don't forget to subscribe to
our podcast on your favorite
platform and leave a five-star
review to help ensure you never
miss an episode and to help
others discover the Curated
Podcast as well.
To stay updated on our upcoming
episodes, as well as our weekly
Twitter space schedule, be sure
to follow us on X, formerly
known as Twitter, at Shiller XYZ
.
Once again, thank you for
tuning in and remember if you're
looking for it art is
everywhere and it's up to us to
appreciate and explore the
emotions it brings to our lives.
Until next time, this is Boone
signing off.